Pramaan · ERP audit

SAP PM pack · v1

Audit the ERP, not the dashboard.

Twenty checks across thirteen SAP PM domains — the first Pramaan ERP audit pack. Every score opens to the records behind it, the benchmark it breached and the transaction that fixes it. Finance and HR packs follow.

How it scores

System / client

SAP S/4HANA · 100

Plant

1000 · Combined Cycle Power Plant

Audit date

2026-11-14

Lead

Demo assessment

Framework

v1.0.0 · 20 of 50 checks

Overall readiness

70%

Audit opinion

Amber

Open findings

6

Risk index

30

Check coverage

20/50

Domain readiness

Sorted by the weakest domain. Colour follows the audit opinion, not the percentage alone.

Audit opinion

Amber

Material gaps exist but none is beyond recovery. Fix the critical records first; the percentage follows.

2 critical7 green domains20 evaluated

Findings by severity

Critical2
High4
Medium0

A domain can be highly compliant and still carry a critical gap. The opinion counts critical failures separately; a high percentage never clears them.

Domain scorecard

Master data and transactional health, by audit domain.

13 domains · 20 checks

Swipe to see all columns →

DomainSectionChecksPassFailReadinessOpinion
Functional locationsMaster data21150%Red
Equipment masterMaster data21150%Red
Equipment & FL BOMsMaster data1010%Red
Work centres & capacityMaster data110100%Green
Task listsMaster data220100%Green
Measuring pointsMaster data220100%Green
Maintenance plansMaster data220100%Green
Catalogs & codesMaster data1010%Red
NotificationsTransactional21150%Red
Orders & backlogTransactional21150%Red
Scheduling & datesTransactional110100%Green
ConfirmationsTransactional110100%Green
ReservationsTransactional110100%Green
Filters20 of 20 checks

Swipe to see all columns →

CheckDomainSeverityResultExceptionsBenchmark
FL-02Active FLOCs missing plant or cost centreFunctional locationsCriticalFail28/22013%0% of active FLOCs missing plant or cost centre
FL-03Active FLOCs without ABC criticalityFunctional locationsHighPass5/2202.3%< 5% of active FLOCs without ABC criticality
EQ-02Class A equipment missing OEM or modelEquipment masterHighPass2/2460.8%< 2% of Class A equipment missing OEM or model
EQ-03Equipment not installed at a functional locationEquipment masterCriticalFail55/8346.6%< 5% of active equipment not installed at a FLOC
BM-01Class A equipment without a spare-parts BOMEquipment & FL BOMsHighFail48/24620%>= 90% of Class A equipment has a BOM
WC-02Work centre without capacityWork centres & capacityCriticalPass0/240%100% of PM work centres have a capacity header
TL-01Task lists not releasedTask listsHighPass7/1504.7%>= 95% of task lists released
TL-02Operations with zero planned workTask listsCriticalPass0/10810%0 operations with zero planned work
MP-01Running-hour points not flagged as countersMeasuring pointsHighPass0/900%100% of counter points flagged as counters
MP-02Condition points without warning limitsMeasuring pointsHighPass5/905.6%>= 90% of condition points have limits
PL-01Plans never scheduledMaintenance plansCriticalPass0/1600%0 active plans left unscheduled
PL-03Plan items without a task listMaintenance plansCriticalPass0/3160%>= 95% of plan items have a task list
CT-02Generic codes dominate the catalogsCatalogs & codesHighFail93/42022%< 15% generic codes in active catalogs
QM-01Open notifications older than 60 daysNotificationsHighFail35/12129%< 10% open notifications older than 60 days
QM-03Closed breakdowns without failure codesNotificationsCriticalPass7/2063.4%>= 95% of closed M2 notifications carry failure codes
AU-01CRTD orders older than 30 daysOrders & backlogHighPass3/803.8%< 5% CRTD orders older than 30 days
AU-02Confirmed orders stuck before TECOOrders & backlogHighFail40/11036%0 CNF orders older than 30 days
AF-01Released orders past their finish dateScheduling & datesHighPass17/1889.0%< 15% released orders past basic finish
FR-04Completed orders with zero confirmed hoursConfirmationsHighPass40/10723.7%< 5% completed orders with zero confirmed hours
RS-01Open reservations on completed ordersReservationsHighPass0/10720%0 open reservations on TECO/CLSD orders

Method

What the number means

Readiness

Passed checks divided by evaluated checks. N/A checks are excluded from both sides.

Risk index

Severity-weighted failures: Critical 5, High 3, Medium 1. Zero is a clean system; 100 is every evaluated check failed.

Audit opinion

Green at 85% readiness with no critical gaps. Amber at 70% with at most two. Everything else is Red.

The other 30 checksCatalogued, not evaluated in this run
Open

Swipe to see all columns →

CheckTitleDomainSeverityBenchmark
FL-01Structure indicator not standardisedFunctional locationsHigh100% standard hierarchy (KKS or ISO 14224)
FL-04Orphan functional locationsFunctional locationsMedium0 orphan sub-locations outside the plant tree
EQ-01Equipment without object typeEquipment masterHigh< 2% equipment without a standard object type
EQ-04Duplicate or scrapped assets still activeEquipment masterHigh0 duplicate active equipment records
EQ-05Missing start-up date or asset linkEquipment masterMedium> 95% major equipment linked to a fixed asset
BM-02BOM items with blocked or obsolete materialsEquipment & FL BOMsHigh0 obsolete materials in active PM BOMs
BM-03FL BOMs not using usage 4 (PM)Equipment & FL BOMsMedium100% PM BOMs created under usage 4
WC-01Work centre maintenance indicator or deletion flagWork centres & capacityHighAll craft disciplines represented and active
WC-03Work centre missing cost centre or activity typeWork centres & capacityCritical100% linked to active CO activity types
TL-03Generic one-line task list operationsTask listsMedium> 85% operations have actionable steps
TL-04Task lists missing material componentsTask listsHigh> 80% major lists include required spares
MP-03Counter rollovers or negative deltasMeasuring pointsMedium0 unvalidated rollovers in 12 months
PL-02Call horizon not set for long-lead workMaintenance plansHigh80–90% call horizon for overhaul plans
PL-04Overdue maintenance callsMaintenance plansCritical0 calls stuck in save-to-call beyond 14 days
PL-05Single-counter plans on critical rotating assetsMaintenance plansMediumMulti-counter strategy on turbines and compressors
CT-01Failure catalogs incomplete or inactiveCatalogs & codesHighAll B/C/5 catalogs active and structured
CT-03Catalog profiles not assigned to notification typesCatalogs & codesHigh100% of M2 types enforce a catalog profile
QM-02Breakdown notifications missing downtime startNotificationsHigh0 M2 notifications without a malfunction start
QM-04Corrective orders created without a notificationNotificationsMedium> 90% corrective orders linked to a notification
AU-03TECO orders not business-closed after 90 daysOrders & backlogHighMonthly settlement and CLSD closure
AU-04Orders without a technical objectOrders & backlogCritical0 maintenance orders without equipment or FLOC
AU-05Released orders without a settlement ruleOrders & backlogCritical100% released orders have a settlement rule
AF-02Reactive vs preventive order mixScheduling & datesHigh70–80% planned work; < 20% breakdown
AF-03Preventive orders generated without a task listScheduling & datesHigh100% preventive orders inherit a task list
AF-04Operations missing a work centreScheduling & datesCritical0 operations without a craft work centre
FR-01Actual hours identical to planned on every orderConfirmationsMedium< 30% 1:1 confirmations
FR-02Confirmation lag beyond 48 hoursConfirmationsMediumConfirmations entered within 24–48 hours
FR-03Partial confirmations left openConfirmationsHighFinal confirmation set on completion
RS-02Past-due reservations with no withdrawalReservationsMediumMonthly cleanup of stale reservations
RS-03Non-stock items without a purchase requisitionReservationsHigh100% non-stock items generate a PR

Definitions

The words that decide which rows enter a check.

Active technical object
Not deletion-flagged (LVORM / LOEKZ) and without system status DLFL or INAC.
Open notification
System status neither NOCO nor CLSD; the notification still requires work.
Released order
Status REL, and not TECO or CLSD.
Overdue order
Basic finish (GLTRP) before the audit date and not technically complete.
Class A equipment
ABC indicator A on EQUI / ILOA. The critical-asset checks use this population.
Evaluated check
A check with a non-zero source population. A missing table or empty population is N/A, never a pass.
Exception %
Failing records divided by the evaluated population for that check. The threshold is the maximum acceptable share.

Scope and sources

  • Pramaan ERP audit · SAP PM pack v1. Finance and HR packs follow the same scoring and evidence model.
  • Primary source: SAP_PM_Complete_Audit_Workbook.xlsx (50 checks, master and transactional).
  • Variant source: SAP_PM_Master_Data_Audit_Checklist.xlsx. Its WC-04 planner-group check and its sampling version of CT-03 are recorded here rather than replacing the primary definitions.
  • Rule definitions for active, open, released and overdue live in definitions.ts and are shown in the Method section.
  • v1 enables 20 checks across all 13 domains; the remaining 30 are catalogued but not evaluated.

What is real here

The rule engine, the scoring and the evidence drill are real. The rows are a deterministic demonstration dataset for a combined-cycle plant. This is the SAP PM pack of the Pramaan ERP audit; finance and HR packs are next. No SAP system is called, and this is not an SAP-certified audit.

The next step is an import of SE16N extracts; the same engine runs on those tables without a server round trip.